Defiance of the law in the essay civil disobedience by henry david thoreau

Civil Disobedience portrayed the problems of the newly formed government. Even though the United States was making great political progress, slavery was still legal in the southern states.

Defiance of the law in the essay civil disobedience by henry david thoreau

Such acts are not committed for personal gain, and maintain a goal of righting an injustice or abuse of governmental policies and laws.

Civil disobedience refers to a deliberate offense against authority committed openly to protest an unjust, arbitrary, cruel, pointless, or immoral law or policy of the government.

Civil disobedience, however, does not refer to just any kind of deliberate violation of law or government policy. Street crimes such as robbery and burglary are committed from motives such as personal gain and malice. The civil disobedient, on the other hand, is not interested in private or personal gain; rather, the purpose of civil disobedience is to protest an injustice or a wrong.

The important defining elements of civil disobedience in this definition are public, nonviolent, deliberate unlawfulness, and conscientious. A Public Act Civil disobedience refers to action that is of a public political nature.

Who can edit:

Acts of disobedience to family and school do not qualify as acts of civil disobedience. Rather, in engaging in openly announced defiance of particular laws or customs, activists are interested in demonstrating that they are withholding allegiance from the state until its alleged abuses are corrected.

Civil disobedients engage in a kind of resistance within the accepted political structure, a violation of the law without loss of respect for law and the other basic political institutions. Civil disobedients want their acts to be nonviolent so that they can convince the majority of their fellow citizens that the acts are indeed conscientious and sincere and that the acts are intended to address what they perceive as an injustice or wrong.

Deliberate Unlawfulness The civil disobedient can use one of two types of deliberate unlawfulness to protest an injustice or wrong.

Direct civil disobedience is a type of deliberate unlawfulness that violates the very law that is the target of the protest. More characteristically, the civil disobedient uses indirect acts of civil disobedience; that is, the act of civil disobedience violates some other law whose reasonableness is not in question.

For example, one does not protest capital punishment for murder by committing murder. Rather, one may protest such perceived wrongs by the disruption of traffic into a correctional facility where an execution is scheduled.

A Conscientious Act This element excludes motives of private or personal gain or malicious emotion as the primary reason for the action. For example, Mohandas Gandhi subverted colonial rule in South Africa and India with acts of passive disobedience.

Civil disobedience - Wikipedia

By so doing, civil disobedients suffer inconvenience, expense, threats, real danger, and eventually punishment. Their willingness to suffer these consequences helps to demonstrate that the purpose of the acts is to protest an injustice or a wrong. Political Authority and Civil Disobedience Judeo-Christian traditions and political philosophy teach that there is a principle of obligation higher than that of human authorities of the political communities, and that in a conflict between the higher and the lower, the higher takes precedence.

In protest of that war, Thoreau refused to pay his taxes, a gesture that led to his spending a night in jail. Moreover, societal reform does not occur through politics.

The regeneration of society, Thoreau insisted, must begin with self-regeneration not political participation. Mohandas Gandhi was a Hindu religious leader and social reformer in India who advocated the use of noncooperation and passive resistance to achieve social and political reform.

Related Questions

He believed that it was not sufficient to rely on persuasion or appeal to authorities to voluntarily change their unjust ways. The condition that justifies civil disobedience is the fundamental violation of human rights. But Gandhi thought that individuals should resort to civil disobedience only after careful consideration and only those who are qualified should practice it.

To be qualified, a person must already have acquired the habit of willing obedience to laws; those who have not learned to obey laws for the right reason do not have the right to disobey the law. King wrote this letter following his arrest for refusing to halt a large civil disobedience campaign.

King called upon citizens to become more involved in politics in order to secure the voting rights that had been denied to black citizens. He believed that civil disobedience presupposes recognizing political authority. King also conceived of civil disobedience as a crisis-heightening tactic that would prod government into a dialogue that would lead to a solution.

Contemporary Issues The historical tradition of civil disobedience lies in religious conscience. The modern discussion of civil disobedience often occurs against a background of acknowledged just constitutions, democratic parliaments, and valid laws.Henry David Thoreau: Was born on July 12th, in Died on May 6th, Was an American author, poet, philosopher, abolitionist, naturalist, tax resister, and leading transcendentalist.

Henry David Thoreau ( 12, – d. May 6, ) was an American writer, naturalist, and philosopher of the Transcendentalist movement.

Defiance of the law in the essay civil disobedience by henry david thoreau

Thoreau was considered to have an incredibly progressive mind for his day, and his work has inspired Mohandas K. Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr., and many others across the world. Henry D. Thoreau’s seminal essay Resistance to Civil Government, better known as On the Duty of Civil Disobedience, outlines his view of the relationship between the state and the individual.

The essay was precipitated by Thoreau’s own act of civil disobedience Thoreau, Henry David. Levin, Jonathan, ed. Walden and Civil Disobedience. Early uses of the term. Thoreau did not coin the term "civil disobedience." However, after his landmark lectures were published in , the term "civil disobedience" began to appear in numerous sermons and lectures relating to slavery and the war in Mexico.

Identify a major point in Thoreau's essay, "On the Duty of Civil Disobedience." 1 educator answer Please summarize Henry David Thoreau's essay "Civil Disobedience" (also known as "Resistance to. Three classic statements on civil disobedience by Henry David Thoreau (–), Mohandas Gandhi (–), and Martin Luther King Jr.

(– ) can illustrate this relationship between political authority and civil disobedience.

Civil Disobedience - Credo Reference